GRATs, Sales to Grantor Trusts, or Private Annuities: Which one is Best?

January 11, 2011 by admin

GRATs, Sales to Grantor Trusts, or Private Annuities: Which one is Best?

Free Online Articles Directory

Why Submit Articles?
Top Authors
Top Articles
FAQ
AB Answers

Publish Article

0 && $.browser.msie ) {
var ie_version = parseInt($.browser.version);
if(ie_version Hello Guest
Login

Email

Password

Remember me?
Lost Password?

Home Page > Law > GRATs, Sales to Grantor Trusts, or Private Annuities: Which one is Best?

GRATs, Sales to Grantor Trusts, or Private Annuities: Which one is Best?

Edit Article |

Posted: Jul 29, 2010 |Comments: 0
|

]]>

This article will compare three popular wealth transfer techniques that all produce potential estate tax savings by removing future appreciation from the transferor’s estate, but without generating significant taxable gifts. Because these techniques produce little, if any, taxable gifts, even those clients who anticipate estate tax repeal (or reform) should not be reluctant to use them. All three techniques also provide the transferor with an income stream for a fixed period. Finally, all three techniques take advantage of the actual rate of return on the transferred assets as compared to the assumed rate of return utilized by the IRS to value the transferred asset. Yet each technique has its advantages and disadvantages when compared to the others.

Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (GRAT).

In the typical GRAT, the grantor contributes income-producing assets (i.e., Subchapter S stock or an interest in an FLP or FLLC) to a trust and receives a fixed payment (the annuity) from the trust each year. Whatever remains in the trust when the GRAT term ends passes to the remainder beneficiaries tax free. For the year the GRAT is created, the grantor has made a taxable gift equal to the difference between the amount contributed (after considering valuation discounts) and the present value of the annuity payments that the grantor will receive. This present value calculation is computed using the IRC Section 7520 rate for the month the GRAT is established. The Section 7520 rate is 120 percent of the annual mid-term applicable federal rate (AFR). Savvy planners will select the combination of annuity payment and trust term that will result in the present value of all future annuity payments equaling the amount initially contributed to the trust. Thus, no (or little) gift tax will be levied. If the GRAT’s actual rate of return exceeds the Section 7520 rate, the excess appreciation will pass to the GRAT remaindermen free of transfer taxes. Additional transfer tax savings occur because the grantor is not separately taxed on the annuity payments, but instead is responsible for paying all of the GRAT’s income taxes. This is because the GRAT will be a “grantor” trust. Rev. Rul. 2004-64. This tax payment is effectively a tax-free gift to the GRAT’s remainder beneficiaries to the extent the GRAT’s income exceeds the annuity payments.

If the grantor dies during the GRAT term, a portion of the GRAT’s assets are included in the grantor’s estate. The portion so included in the amount necessary to produce the retained interest in perpetuity (as if the annuity amount were the annual income of the GRAT’s assets) using the IRC Section 7520 rate in effect on the date of death (or the alternate valuation date). Generally, if a GRAT’s assets have substantially appreciated, there will be a significant tax-free transfer of wealth even if the grantor dies during the term.

Intentionally Defective Irrevocable Trust (IDIT).

An intentionally defective irrevocable trust is an irrevocable trust that the grantor purposely creates to be “defective” for income tax purposes, but “effective” for transfer tax purposes. If properly designed, the IRS treats the grantor as the owner of the trust’s assets only for income tax purposes (a so-called “grantor” trust). After the IDIT is established and a small gift (i.e., seed money) is made to the trust, the grantor sells income-producing assets (i.e., Subchapter S stock or interests in a family LLC) to the trust in exchange for the trust’s installment note. The sales price will consider valuation discounts.

In the typical sale to an IDIT no down payment is made, the IDIT pays the grantor annually interest only at the AFR for the month of the sale, and there is a balloon payment at the end of nine or more years. Because the sale is between the grantor and his/her grantor trust, the IRS does not recognize any gain or loss on the sale. Under Rev. Rul. 85-13, transactions between a grantor and his/her grantor trust are disregarded for income tax purposes. If the assets in the IDIT appreciate greater than the AFR, such excess value is removed from the grantor’s estate. Additional transfer tax savings occur because the grantor is not separately taxed on the interest payments, but instead is responsible for paying all of the IDIT’s income taxes. This tax payment is effectively a tax-free gift to the beneficiaries of the IDIT to the extent the IDIT’s income exceeds the interest payments. Rev. Rul. 2004-64.

Private Annuity.

A private annuity is a contractual arrangement that is very much like an installment sale, except that the payments must continue until the seller’s death. In the typical private annuity, a parent (seller) sells income producing assets (i.e., Subchapter S stock or interests in a family LLC) to a child (buyer). The sales price will consider valuation discounts. The buyer takes legal title to the property and promises to make payments (the annuity) to the seller for the rest of the seller’s lifetime. The amount of the annuity is determined by IRS actuarial tables established under IRC Section 7520. Until April 18, 2007, the annuitant (seller) was able to report the built-in gain on the property sold piecemeal as part of each annuity payment. Under current law, the entire amount of the seller’s gain or loss (if any) must be recognized at the time of sale. Thus, part of each payment will now be a tax-free return of basis and part will be interest income. Each payment made by the purchaser is added to his/her basis in the property and no portion of the payment is deductible to the seller. If the value of the private annuity received by the seller equals the transferred property’s fair market value, then no gift tax will be incurred.

How They Stack Up

Mortality Risk. In a GRAT, if the grantor does not survive the fixed term, a portion of the assets in the GRAT are included in the grantor’s estate. In contrast, there is no such mortality risk with an IDIT. However, with an IDIT there is a risk that if the grantor dies before the note is paid off, any gain on the outstanding note must be recognized. With a private annuity, a short life span simply enhances the efficacy of the transaction. It must be noted, however, that the actuarial tables cannot be used to determine the amount of the private annuity where the seller is “terminally ill” (i.e., has at least a 50 percent probability of dying within one year of the sale).

Disadvantage: GRAT.

Taxable Gift. As a result of the Tax Court’s holding in Walton, 115 T.C. 589, it is now possible to “zero-out” a GRAT so that no taxable gift occurs. For sales to an IDIT, most planners believe that the IDIT should have some equity (seed money) to avoid potential transfer tax issues. Therefore, it is advisable for the grantor to make a gift to the IDIT in the range of 10 percent of the value of the property to be sold to the trust. Private annuities can be easily structured without incurring a taxable gift.

Disadvantage: IDIT.

Hard To Value Assets. Where hard to value assets are involved, or where valuation discounts are being taken, the GRAT offers a significant advantage over an IDIT or a private annuity. The reason is that the GRAT regulations allow the annuity to be set forth as a percentage of the initial value of the assets transferred to the GRAT. Therefore, if the GRAT’s assets are revalued as a result of a gift tax audit, the amount of the annuity automatically adjusts thereby minimizing any unexpected gift tax.

Advantage: GRAT.

Generation Skipping Tax Exemption. Because of the estate tax inclusion period (ETIP) rules, the grantor’s generation skipping tax (GST) exemption cannot be allocated to the initial contribution to the GRAT. Instead, the grantor must wait until the end of the GRAT term to allocate his/her GST exemption. With an IDIT, the grantor can allocate his/her GST exemption, but only has to do so to the extent of any seed money gifted to the IDIT. Since a private annuity does not usually generate a taxable gift, there are no GST implications to that technique.

Disadvantage: GRAT.

Grantor Trust Status. As mentioned above, the grantor’s payment of income taxes on behalf of a “grantor trust” is effectively a tax-free gift to the trust’s beneficiaries. Since GRATs and IDITs are both grantor trusts, to the extent that their income exceeds the annuity payment (for GRATs) or the interest payment (for IDITs), such excess is transferred to the trust’s beneficiaries tax-free. No such opportunity is available with a standard private annuity transaction, unless the sale is made to a private annuity trust designed as an IDIT.

Disadvantage: Private Annuity.

Interest Rates. The lower the assumed interest rate the more leverage possible. For GRATs and private annuities the assumed interest rate is the IRC Section 7520 rate which is 120 percent of the mid-term AFR. In comparison, the installment note used in a sale to an IDIT need bear interest at only the AFR.

Advantage: IDIT.

Backloading. With a GRAT, the annuity payment can increase annually, but not more than 20% over the previous year. A private annuity requires equal periodic payments. In contrast, most installment sales to IDITs are structured as interest-only with a balloon payment. Therefore, the less paid out annually to the grantor, the more appreciation passing to the grantor’s heirs.

Advantage: IDIT.

Security. A private annuity cannot be secured. Thus, the seller must rely on the buyer’s ability to pay. In comparison, with GRATs and IDITs, the grantor is protected because the transferred assets are held in trust until the end of the term (with GRATs) or until the note is fully paid (with IDITs).

Disadvantage: Private Annuity.

Overpayment. The total amount to be paid to the grantor with either a GRAT or IDIT is fixed. However, with a private annuity, if the seller lives past his/her life expectancy, it is possible that all of the assets sold (plus the appreciation thereon) will be returned to the seller, and possibly some of the purchaser’s assets as well. ôEUREUR¹ Disadvantage: Private Annuity. Gain Recognition. GRATs and IDITs (where the installment note is paid prior to the grantor’s death) involve no gain recognition to the grantor. In contrast, private annuities cause the transferor to recognize gain at the time of the sale.

Disadvantage: Private Annuity.

Certainty. A GRAT is a statutory technique governed by IRC Section 2702. Private annuities are generally governed by the regulations under IRC Section 7520. In comparison, installment sales to IDITs are based upon an amalgamation of public and private revenue rulings and case law.

Disadvantage: IDIT.

Life Insurance Applications. Life insurance can add value to all three wealth transfer techniques. In the context of a GRAT, a policy on the grantor’s life owned by an irrevocable trust can be used as a “hedge” to provide the liquidity – both income and estate tax free – to pay the estate taxes due if the grantor does not survive the GRAT term. With the typical IDIT, the income earned by the trust (in excess of the interest payments due the grantor) can be used to purchase life insurance thereby “leveraging” the grantor’s GST exemption. Finally, with a private annuity, a policy on the buyer’s life can provide a source of funds to “assure” the annuity payments continue in the event the buyer predeceases the seller.

Advantage: Life Insurance.

Conclusion. Whether a GRAT, IDIT or private annuity should be used in a particular situation is fact specific. Each technique, while similar in many ways, has advantages and disadvantages when compared to the other two strategies. Thus, a careful analysis of each strategy must be made (preferably with the client’s involvement) before implementing a particular course of action.

THIS ARTICLE MAY NOT BE USED FOR PENALTY PROTECTION. THE MATERIAL IS BASED UPON GENERAL TAX RULES AND FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY. IT IS NOT INTENDED AS LEGAL OR TAX ADVICE AND TAXPAYERS SHOULD CONSULT THEIR OWN LEGAL AND TAX ADVISORS AS TO THEIR SPECIFIC SITUATION.

Retrieved from “http://www.articlesbase.com/law-articles/grats-sales-to-grantor-trusts-or-private-annuities-which-one-is-best-2926060.html”

(ArticlesBase SC #2926060)

Liked this article? Click here to publish it on your website or blog, it’s free and easy!

Julius Giarmarco, Esq. -
About the Author:

Julius Giarmarco, Esq. of Giarmarco, Mullins & Horton, P.C. is a partner and heads up the firm’s Trusts and Estates Practice Group. Julius received his law degree (J.D.) from Wayne State University, and his master of laws (LL.M.) from New York University. His primary practice areas include estate planning, business succession planning, wealth transfer planning, and life insurance applications. Julius is a former instructor in both the Chartered Life Underwriter (CLU) and Certified Financial Planner (CFP) programs. He also lectures frequently on a national basis, including speeches before the American Law Institute – American Bar Association (ALI-ABA), the International Forum, the Association for Advanced Life Underwriting (AALU), the Million Dollar Round Table (MDRT), and numerous life insurance companies, brokerage firms and trade associations. Julius has published a number of articles on estate planning appearing in professional journals such as the Estates, Gifts and Trusts Journal (BNA), The Practical Tax Lawyer (ALI-ABA), the Journal of Practical Estate Planning (CCH) and Advisor Today. Julius is also the author of the nationally acclaimed brochure, The Five Levels of Estate Planning, and the co-author of the book, Estate Planning with Insurance. He is the author of the chapters on succession planning in Advising Closely Held Businesses in Michigan and The Michigan Business Formbook published by the Institute of Continuing Legal Education (ICLE). Julius has also been selected by his peers as a Michigan “Super Lawyer” in estate planning.

]]>

Questions and Answers

Ask our experts your Law related questions here…200 Characters left

I am having more clients who are interesting to invest money in private placement program in INDIA. Please suggest me the best option for bullet trading. Dr. V. B. Rao Dasari drvbraodasari@gmail.com
My husband and i are going thru a divorce and he recently made “himself” a corporation, Ens legis Trust Private. my atty. says he cannot be sued, served papers or brought to court, is this true?
Who has the best PDF Re-brander software available for sale?… 1. I require an unbranded script I can host on my site. 2. PDF & re-brander to be hosted at my site & have friendly interface

Rate this Article

1
2
3
4
5

vote(s)
0 vote(s)

Feedback
RSS
Print
Email
Re-Publish

Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/law-articles/grats-sales-to-grantor-trusts-or-private-annuities-which-one-is-best-2926060.html

Article Tags:
grat, idit, private annuity, life insurance

Latest Law Articles
More from Julius Giarmarco, Esq.

Estate Planning in Los Angeles

Learn tips about estate planning by a Los Angeles estate planning attorney

By:
Jonathan Carlsonl
Lawl
Aug 22, 2009

Tips To Get An Appropriate Legal Advisor

If you are looking for a right legal professional, just go with your analysis. Study your case, and then it is possible that you hire a professional that will add strength to your case with his experience.

By:
Stewart Wrighterl
Lawl
Jan 10, 2011

Maryland Criminal Records History Checks – you get free background check?

There are several ways to get the police, who are Maryland criminal records and some forms of detailed than others. There are many pages, so that background checks for free.

By:
Andy Wongl
Lawl
Jan 10, 2011

How to Find Free Public Court Minnesota Marriage Records?

There are several reasons why people have to court documents. Try to find these documents on-line directories and even court proceedings.

By:
Andy Wongl
Lawl
Jan 10, 2011

How Insurance Companies Can Harm Your Claim

The insurance company may seem sympathetic to your losses, but remember that they’re a business looking out for their bottom line. Beware some of the tactics they use to make you settle for less.

By:
Benjamin Glassl
Lawl
Jan 10, 2011

Remove and discard the criminal refused – All RI Criminal Records are bad!

Remove all the criminals and not guilty findings dismissal of RI criminal records!

By:
Andy Wongl
Lawl
Jan 10, 2011

How to Find a Free Texas License Plate Search

Get a Free Search in texas license plate search is not ,

By:
Andy Wongl
Lawl
Jan 10, 2011

Free Criminal Record Check – How to query and browse the online predators

If you expect a national database of free criminal record check of charge to facilitate era of modern communications, and then be disappointed. Technology is available, and the Federal Constitution guarantees the protection of American citizens access to information, but state law specifically required for the implementation.

By:
Andy Wongl
Lawl
Jan 10, 2011

Information on Divorce Records Florida

Sunshine State is not all sunshine. The greatest number of distinctions between the states to monitor statistics. Currently, five divorces per 1000 population in Florida. For a population of 20 million U.S. state of Florida one of the absolute number of Divorce Records Florida. Millions of divorce documents filed in Florida state archives, and control the county level is much, much more.

By:
Andy Wongl
Lawl
Jan 10, 2011

GRATs, Sales to Grantor Trusts, or Private Annuities: Which one is Best?

Whether a GRAT, IDIT or private annuity should be used in a particular situation is fact specific. Each technique, while similar in many ways, has advantages and disadvantages when compared to the other two strategies. Thus, a careful analysis of each strategy must be made (preferably with the client’s involvement) before implementing a particular course of action.

By:
Julius Giarmarco, Esq.l
Lawl
Jul 29, 2010

Grantor Retained Annuity Trusts

While there is a present lapse in the estate and generation-skipping transfer taxes, GRATs will continue to be useful to leverage the amount a grantor can give.

By:
Julius Giarmarco, Esq.l

Finance>
Wealth Buildingl
Jul 29, 2010

Gifting of LLC / FLP Interests to Family Members – Timing is Everything

The IRS has never liked valuation discounts (for lack of control and marketability) and has attempted to attack gifts of limited liability company (LLC) and family limited partnership (FLP) interests under several theories over the years and with varying success. But recently the IRS has been successful in using the indirect gift theory and the step-transaction doctrine to disallow valuation discounts in connection with gifts of LLC and FLP interests.

By:
Julius Giarmarco, Esq.l
Lawl
Jul 06, 2010

Five Levels of Estate Planning

With some advanced planning, it is possible to reduce estate taxes, avoid probate, set forth your wishes, and protect your heirs from creditors, ex-spouses and estate taxes.

By:
Julius Giarmarco, Esq.l
Lawl
Jul 06, 2010

BENEFICIARY DEFECTIVE IRREVOCABLE TRUSTS

A Beneficiary Defective Irrevocable Trust allows the beneficiary to achieve virtually all of his/her tax and non-tax planning objectives. When advising clients on estate planning matters, the planner should advise them to consider establishing BDITs for their children and grandchildren, and/or advise them to ask their parents and grandparents to establish a BDIT for them.

By:
Julius Giarmarco, Esq.l
Lawl
Jun 18, 2010
lViews: 228

Beneficiary-Controlled Trusts

In short, a beneficiary-controlled trust should be considered whenever it is worthwhile to protect beneficiaries from creditors, divorcing spouses and estate taxes.

By:
Julius Giarmarco, Esq.l
Lawl
Jun 18, 2010

Avoiding the Three Year Life Insurance Transfer Rule

This article explains how to avoid IRC Section 2035, which brings life insurance policies transferred within three years of death, back into the insured’s gross estate.

By:
Julius Giarmarco, Esq.l
Lawl
Jun 18, 2010
lViews: 147

An Alternative to a Buy-Sell Agreement

While the no-sell/buy-sell may not work for everyone, it is a unique and potentially beneficial alternative to the traditional automatic buy-out upon the death or retirement of the business owner. The benefits to the participants, including the surviving owners, can be substantial. No longer need the last man standing be the big winner.

By:
Julius Giarmarco, Esq.l
Lawl
Jun 18, 2010

Add new Comment

Your Name: *

Your Email:

Comment Body: *

Verification code:*

* Required fields

Submit

Your Articles Here
It’s Free and easy

Author Navigation

My Home
Publish Article
View/Edit Articles
View/Edit Q&A
Edit your Account
Manage Authors
Statistics Page
Personal RSS Builder

My Home
Edit your Account
Update Profile
View/Edit Q&A
Publish Article
Author Box

Julius Giarmarco, Esq. has 11 articles online

Articles Categories
All Categories

Advertising
Arts & Entertainment
Automotive
Beauty
Business
Careers
Computers
Education
Finance
Food and Beverage
Health
Hobbies
Home and Family
Home Improvement
Internet
Law
Marketing
News and Society
Relationships
Self Improvement
Shopping
Spirituality
Sports and Fitness
Technology
Travel
Writing

Law

Bankruptcy
Copyright
Criminal
Cyber Law
Health and Safety
Immigration
Intellectual Property
Internet Law
National, State, Local
Patents
Personal Injury
Regulatory Compliance
Trademarks

]]>

Need Help?
Contact Us
FAQ
Submit Articles
Editorial Guidelines
Blog

Site Links
Recent Articles
Top Authors
Top Articles
Find Articles
Site Map

Webmasters
RSS Builder
RSS
Link to Us

Business Info
Advertising

Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2011 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved.

You know the old saying: Kill two birds with one stone?It’s just a saying …Annuities are like that… they’re tax-deferred retirement savings plans, but they’re also insurance policies. When you buy an annuity, you’re investing a certain amount of money with an insurance company. The insurer promises to credit earnings to your account and to annuitize your account value. Annuitization means that insurer will return your principal and earnings to you in regular payments – guaranteed – for the rest of your life. Or, if you prefer, you can withdraw your money as you need it. Some investors use annuities as a way to accumulate tax-deferred earnings without planning to annuitize. Others buy annuities as a personal pension, to provide a stream of guaranteed lifetime income, and to have a good life insurance policy, to protect the family.

GRATs, Sales to Grantor Trusts, or Private Annuities: Which one is Best?

Leave a Reply

Meta

Recent Articles

Categories