What are the pros and cons of a variable annuity?

January 16, 2010 by admin

Question by Steve K: What are the pros and cons of a variable annuity?
My recently-retired parents have a lump sum of money (sizable but not huge) and have been recommended a variable annuity by a financial adviser. I have heard annuities are generally a bad investment because they have high fees, but a guaranteed return for them would be desirable. Can I get some pros and cons for a variable annuity in this specific situation?

Best answer:

Answer by Net Advisor
Pros:
1. Broker usually gets 5% commission on the sale.

2. “Growth” is tax deferred until withdrawn. Taxed at ordinary income levels on withdraws. 10% IRS penalty for withdraws if under 59 1/2.

Cons:
1. Insurance Company default risk. They are all in deep ca ca right now (AIG, AXA, AZ, HIG, ING, MET, etc..). I’d avoid them.

2. Long time 8-10 years back end load. Pay a penalty if take money out or move it elsewhere.

3. NO guarantees on investment performance, except fixed account which will not keep up with inflation. The “Guaranteed return,” typically a “GIC – Guaranteed Investment Contract” is ONLY guaranteed by the full faith and credit of the insurance company – not guaranteed by any government agency. Guarantee is void if company goes under.

If they tell you there are “fine, a strong company, how long they have been in business, their credit rating, etc., run! Look at their stock price! The only solid insurance co I know of is not public traded – USAA. (member restricted).

https://www.usaa.com/inet/ent_utils/McStaticPages?key=become_member_main

4. Annual BS “contract fee” changed by insur companies in addition to the fees charged by the funds in the annuity.

5. If their F/A has less than 15 year exp, or esp under 5 years exp, find someone else.

6. If their F/A only sells, or primary sells insurance products, works for a bank or insurance company, RUN! They don’t have the training, advanced licensing, or experience necessary to understand markets.

I have been saying since 1995 that banks and insurance companies are poor money mangers. Now we all know this.

I would rather put that money in a Roth IRA if the money they have is NOT from a 401(k) or existing qualified retirement plan.

I would be looking at FDIC insured short term (under 1 year, pref 3-6 months and roll them) CD’s, or Treasury Inflation Protected Securities (TIPS).

http://www.treasurydirect.gov/indiv/products/prod_tips_glance.htm

I was insurance licensed since 1995, “retired” from this end now.

Give your answer to this question below!

The Truth About Buying Annuities

ISBN13: 9780132353083
Condition: NEW
Notes: Brand New from Publisher. No Remainder Mark.

Avoid the retirement annuity minefield…don’t make an expensive, catastrophic mistake! · The truth about using annuities to protect your future · The truth about hidden fees that could cost you a fortune · The truth about the newest types of annuities–good and bad Simply the best thinking…the truth and nothing but the truth This book reveals the 50 CRITICAL FACTS you must know about annuities before you buy “Steve Weisman has accomplished a feat of immense proportion by explaining one of the most complicated investment vehicles in ways that average Americans can easily understand.” Robert Powell, Editor, “Retirement Weekly,” MarketWatch Introduction v Truth 1 The history of annuities 1 Truth 2 Immediate annuities 5 Truth 3 Fixed rates 9 Truth 4 Deferred annuities 13 Truth 5 Annuity fees 17 Truth 6 Variable

Rating: (out of 5 reviews)

List Price: $ 18.99

Price: $ 11.50

Tag: Annuity, cons, contract fee, default risk, financial adviser, guaranteed investment contract, guaranteed return, insurance products, irs penalty, pros, strong company, usaa, variable, variable annuity

What are the pros and cons of a variable annuity?

The Truth About Buying Annuities

Leave a Reply

Meta

Recent Articles

Categories